Riway MLM Price Wars
Disclaimer! Neither Riway could have avoided this, however, Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) companies often struggle with price wars due to a combination of structural, economic, and competitive factors. Here’s why:
1. Overpriced Products
- Premium Pricing: Many MLM businesses tend to sell products at a premium price, relying on the structure of the business to create the perception of value. When a price war starts, these high prices become difficult to sustain. In such case, same for Riway’s Purtier deer placenta.
- Price Sensitivity: MLM products are often perceived as overpriced, especially when compared to similar products in regular retail stores. In a price war, the prices of competitors may be significantly lower, making MLM offerings seem less attractive.
2. Dependence on Recruitment, Not Retail Sales
- Emphasis on Recruitment Over Sales: MLM companies often incentivize distributors more for recruiting others than for selling products. As a result, the products themselves are sometimes priced higher because distributors are earning commissions based on recruitment and sales volume, not just the value of the product itself.
- Margin Squeeze: If competitors in a price war offer lower prices, MLM distributors can’t easily drop their prices without eroding their own profit margins, which are already stretched thin due to commission structures.
3. Lack of Economies of Scale
- Higher Operational Costs: Many MLMs are smaller compared to traditional businesses and might not have the economies of scale necessary to lower prices without cutting into their profit margins. Large-scale manufacturers or retailers can often afford to reduce prices due to their scale, whereas MLMs may not have the same leverage.
- Fixed Costs: With large upline/downline structures, MLMs have fixed costs tied to their compensation system that competitors don’t have. A price war forces them to maintain profitability while distributors and employees expect their commissions.
4. Complicated Pricing Structures
- Complicated Compensation Plans: Many MLMs use complex compensation structures (e.g., binary plans, unilevel systems) that require a certain pricing level to sustain the commissions. If the price drops too much, the MLM model itself can become unviable.
- Focus on Recruitment Bonuses: Lowering product prices would reduce the revenue generated per sale, which directly affects the bonuses and commissions paid to recruiters and downline members, creating internal resistance to price cuts.
5. Brand Perception Issues
- Value vs. Price Perception: If the company is already fighting a perception problem regarding the value of its product, entering a price war could further damage its image. Consumers may already view MLM products as overpriced, and lowering the price might reinforce that negative perception, making it harder to attract customers who want to feel they’re getting good value for their money.
- Inconsistent Pricing: Price wars can lead to inconsistent pricing strategies across different markets or distributors, creating confusion among consumers. This can damage brand trust and reduce overall sales.
6. Incentive to Undercut Prices
- Distributors Underpricing: In some MLMs, individual distributors may undercut the official pricing of the product in order to sell more quickly, especially if they are competing for recruitment. This can lead to price fragmentation, eroding the brand’s value.
- Conflict of Interests: Distributors might engage in their own “price wars” without regard for the company’s overall pricing strategy, which further destabilizes the business.
7. Saturated Markets
- Market Saturation: In a competitive price war, MLM businesses can quickly reach market saturation, where most potential customers have already been approached or recruited. This makes it harder for MLM distributors to rely on recruitment to maintain their sales, forcing them into a more price-sensitive environment where low-cost competitors dominate.
- Limited Customer Base: Since MLMs often rely on a small, niche customer base (often within the distributor’s network), they are more vulnerable to price wars, especially when the competition offers broader, more competitive reach.
8. Legal and Regulatory Scrutiny
- Regulatory Issues: Price wars in MLMs can attract the attention of regulators, especially when pricing practices become unsustainable or unfair to consumers and distributors. Some countries have strict laws governing MLMs, and a price war could lead to scrutiny on whether the pricing is misleading or manipulative.
9. Reliance on Direct Sales
- Dependence on Personal Selling: Many MLMs rely on personal sales efforts by distributors, which means they don’t benefit as much from traditional marketing or advertising channels. As such, when the competition enters a price war, it’s harder for MLMs to sustain the same level of visibility without dramatically increasing marketing costs.
- Limited Product Reach: Unlike traditional retail or e-commerce, MLMs usually have limited direct access to larger, more price-sensitive customer pools. Price wars often shift customer preferences toward businesses with broader distribution channels and more competitive pricing.
10. Focus on Long-Term Recruitment Over Immediate Sales
- Long Sales Cycles: Since MLM businesses are often more focused on long-term recruitment and the building of downlines rather than quick retail sales, they are not agile enough to quickly react to price wars. Competitors with lower overheads and faster, more efficient sales processes will often win in a price-sensitive market.
Conclusion
In essence, MLM companies are built on a unique business model that places greater importance on recruitment and distribution than on competitive pricing. This makes them vulnerable in price wars, where their reliance on premium pricing and commission-based structures prevents them from adapting quickly to market pressures. As competitors engage in aggressive price cutting, MLMs are forced to either maintain higher prices (which alienates consumers) or reduce their profit margins, ultimately undermining the business model.